Home

What Is the Difference Between Colour Pencils, Crayons and Oil Pastels?

Colour pencils, crayons and oil pastels differ mainly in their binders, firmness and the marks they leave. Colour pencils give you precision, wax crayons leave broad, textured marks, and oil pastels produce soft, dense strokes. Choose pencils for detail, crayons for simple colouring and oil pastels for rich coverage and blending.

What are colour pencils, crayons and oil pastels made of?

A colour pencil usually has a core of pigment, binders and fillers enclosed in wood. Conventional artist pencils commonly use wax-based or oil-based binders, though manufacturers use different formulations. The core isn't graphite, even though the pencil looks similar to a writing pencil.

Ordinary wax crayons combine colouring material with wax and usually come as unsharpened sticks. Their relatively firm consistency suits broad strokes, rubbings and simple colouring. The word ‘crayon’ can also describe other drawing sticks, so check that the pack says wax crayons if that's what you need.

Oil pastels combine pigment with an oil-and-wax binder. They feel softer and creamier than ordinary crayons, though firmness varies considerably between ranges. Don't confuse them with dry soft pastels, which leave powdery marks, or water-soluble pastels, which you can spread with water.

How do their marks and colours differ?

A sharpened pencil point gives you the greatest control over small shapes, fine outlines, hair, lettering and narrow spaces. Light pressure leaves a pale layer; repeated layers deepen the colour. Harder cores generally hold a fine point longer, while softer cores lay down colour more readily but need more frequent sharpening.

Wax crayons leave wider, often grainier marks because the colour catches on the raised texture of the paper. You can use the tip for outlines or the side for broad areas. You'll find them less suitable for intricate details, particularly once the tip becomes rounded.

Oil pastels usually leave a thicker layer with less effort. Use their broad tips for bold shapes and large areas, or an edge for narrower lines. You'll find crisp detail in very small areas harder to maintain because the stick softens and picks up other colours as you work.

Don't judge colour strength by the medium alone. Pigment content, fillers, paper and pressure all affect the result. You can get a richer mark from a good colour pencil than from a poorly formulated oil pastel.

Which is best for blending and layering?

With colour pencils, build several light layers rather than pressing hard straight away. You can overlap colours, hatch with closely spaced lines or cross-hatch with intersecting lines. The paper's tooth, or surface texture, holds the colour; heavy pressure flattens that texture and makes further layering harder.

To burnish, press firmly with a pale pencil or a suitable colourless blender to smooth the layers. Save this for the later stages of your drawing. You can lift some lightly applied colour with a kneaded eraser, but you'll rarely remove dark or heavily burnished marks completely.

You can overlap and mix colours with wax crayons, but ordinary varieties generally resist smooth blending. Use them when you want visible strokes, textured fills or scratch-back designs. To make a scratch-back design, scrape through a top layer to reveal another colour underneath.

You'll usually find oil pastels the easiest of the three to blend directly. Overlap adjoining colours and work them together with another pastel or a paper blending stump. Wipe the stick before switching colours, and avoid overworking several colours together, as you may end up with a muddy mixture.

What paper should you use?

Match the surface to your technique rather than automatically buying thick paper. Paper weight, stated in gsm, describes mass per square metre. It doesn't tell you how rough or absorbent the surface is, or how well it will suit your technique.

  • For colour pencils, choose smooth to lightly textured drawing paper. Smooth paper supports fine detail, while a little texture gives you more scope for layering.
  • For wax crayons, use ordinary drawing paper or sturdy colouring sheets with a slight texture. You may get patchy coverage on very glossy paper.
  • For oil pastels, choose sturdy drawing paper, mixed-media paper or paper labelled for oil pastels. A slightly textured surface helps grip the colour.

Use thin colouring-book pages for gentle pencil work rather than heavy pastel application or vigorous rubbing. Test the back page first, especially if the book has printing on both sides. For artwork you intend to keep, choose acid-free paper and check the lightfastness rating of each colour you use. This tells you how well it resists fading under light.

Which should you choose for your drawing?

Base your choice on the size of the drawing, the finish you want and how much preparation or cleaning you're willing to do. You won't necessarily find a larger set more useful than a smaller set that works well on your paper.

  • Choose colour pencils for detailed colouring books, botanical studies, diagrams and controlled shading.
  • Choose wax crayons for simple shapes, broad colouring, texture rubbings and activities that need little preparation.
  • Choose oil pastels for bold drawings, expressive strokes, layered colour and blending over larger areas.
  • For young children, select age-appropriate products with barrels or sticks thick enough for them to grip comfortably.

Before buying, check whether you can buy individual colours separately, particularly for pencils and pastels you expect to use often. If you can test samples, compare how evenly they cover the same sheet, how readily their tips break or crumble, and how well the colours blend. Check that your sharpener accepts the pencil diameter.

How should you store your supplies and drawings?

Keep pencil points protected and avoid dropping pencils, as the cores can break inside the wood. Store crayons and oil pastels in divided trays or their original packaging so the sticks don't rub together. Clean pastel tips on scrap paper rather than letting transferred colour spoil your next drawing.

Oil pastels remain smudgeable, so don't stack finished sheets face to face. Place sheets of glassine between stored drawings, and keep framed work from touching the glazing. Use a fixative only if its manufacturer explicitly states that it suits oil pastels; ordinary pastel fixative may not give you the result you expect.

Keep finished drawings away from direct sunlight and limit their exposure to other light. The Library of Congress recommends limiting light exposure when caring for works on paper. Store drawings flat in a suitable folder, without tight bands or clips that could mark the surface.

Sources